2.1 Synopsis
CMRNP is an area of globally significant biodiversity. It is an internationally recognised Important Bird Area and has very high level of habitat and species diversity and endemism. The rugged topography has created unique habitats occupied by species with very small ecological envelopes. Historical circumstances and socio-political events have resulted in a diverse ethnic and cultural make-up of surrounding communities. Access to services and development opportunities and is not uniform, with some groups less able to benefit from development schemes and being more disadvantaged.
The AHP provides a number of life-sustaining and irreplaceable ecosystem goods and services ranging from its genetic reserves, water provisioning, micro-climate stabilisation through to carbon capture and sequestration and recreation.
The AHP has a management structure and an approved plan of management (the SFMP). Financing of the AHP is through a mix of government subvention and PFES. Forecast park expenditures according to the SFMP exceed the annual budget allocation.
CMRNP faces numerous challenges due to climate change, anthropogenic pressures, insufficient resources for management and historical events. Local social and development plans promote intensive agriculture outside the AHP. These factors place increasing pressures on the natural values of the CMRNP. Internal roads and tourism development combined with areas of intensive agriculture surrounding the park have created a very hard border in many areas, fragmenting and isolating ecosystems and habitats creating a high risk of species loss from the AHP itself. The AHP faces genetic isolation, hard boundaries, higher risk of species extinction and increased vulnerability to stochastic and catastrophic events, a process which will be exacerbated by climate change.
The role of modern protected areas is evolving rapidly. Traditional staff capacities, often drawn from a forestry background, struggle to keep abreast of the increasingly complex challenges of park management, adding a multiplicity of tasks and skill requirements ranging from law enforcement through biodiversity and ecosystem monitoring to visitor management. Matching human resources to changing job roles is challenging and often requires a range of approaches from re-skilling existing staff, in-service training, diversifying employment backgrounds to investing in long term education.
The policy and planning framework, which provides the rationale for the trade-offs between ecosystem resilience and economic development (the SFMP), leans towards investment in economic development, often at the expense of biodiversity conservation. As such, there is a risk that development of CMRNP is focused on investment opportunities and not necessarily on the AHP’s ability to continue functioning as a coherent and resilient system, providing a wide range of ecosystem goods and services.
While the policy and regulatory framework is developed, it still requires adjustments to balance the costs and benefits, responsibilities and authorities and develop effective common pool resources management. Some of the challenges to management such as the functional efficiency of PES schemes to finance forest protection lie outside the influence of the AHP management.
CMRNP also faces considerable financial challenges. There is an underfinancing of operational and development aspects of the SFMP due to low forecasting of cost involved compared to actual cost. Furthermore, the financial constraints combined with the pressures to generate its own revenues makes the park vulnerable to inappropriate development and diminishes their powers of negotiation with external interests with regards to concessionary fees and rents.
The SGP packages (general park management, wildlife research and monitoring) are designed to support this process of adapting or fine-tuning existing policies and plans towards an agreed AHP goal by:
- Building AHP capacity in biodiversity management and monitoring and linking this to an adaptive planning process;
- building AHP management to identify, access and manage additional sources of AHP financing;
- Building the AHP staff to carry out conservation measures such as experimental management, management-orientated survey and monitoring and evaluation;
- Building practical linkages with other institutions providing expertise, specialist equipment and mentoring;
- Improving language skills in management and tourism services;
- Improving the financial planning capacity;
- Directly financing management-orientated research and monitoring, and;
- Directly financing specific activities which reduce tensions between AHP and local communities.
- raising awareness of a broad cross section of stakeholders, and;
- directly financing specific activities which reduce tensions between AHP and local communities.
2.2 Location and Area
In 2020, Chu Mom Ray National Park (140 18′ to 140 38′ North latitude, 1070 29′ to 107 o 47′ East longitude) has a total area of 56,257.2 ha and is divided into 3 subdivisions including (1) strictly protected subdivision, (2) ecological restoration subdivision, and (3) administrative service and tourism subdivision (SFMP, 2021)
- (SPS): This subdivision has a total area of 19,821.8 ha, accounting for 35.23% of the total area of special-use forest of the park. In the SPS, natural forests accounts for the majority (99.33%) of the whole area and this is the distribution area of most of the rich and medium timber forests of the park. However, there are still poor forest areas in the SPS, mainly distributed in areas adjacent to the ecological restoration and administrative services and tourism zones. The SPS area mainly distributes in the slopes and peaks of mountain ranges in eastern and western region of the CMRNP with mainly low and medium altitude terrain.
- (ERS): This zone has a total area of 28,964.8 ha, accounting for 51.49% of the total special-use forest area of the park. In ERS, the forests accounts for 95.25% of the whole area. Most of the forests in ERS area has been affected. Poor forest, mixed timber-bamboo forest and bamboo forest occupy most of ERS area. The ERS area mainly distributes in the slopes and foothills of the low mountains and hills and the terraces along the Ya Book valley, and being adjacent to the buffer zone communes.
- vision (ASTS): This zone has a total area of about 5,796.9 ha, accounting for 10.30% of the total area of special-use forests of the park. The ASTS area distributes mainly in Ya Book area, stretching along National Highway 14 and the area of deciduous forest in Dak Kan commune. In the zone, Bar Goc is the area for Botanical Garden, Orchid Garden and Center for Biodiversity Conservation and Ecotourism.
| Figure 1. Chu Mom Ray National Park and its buffer zone |
The buffer zone of CMRNP covers an area of 88,925.6 ha in 8 communes and 1 town, including Bo Y, Sa Loong and Đak Kan (Ngoc Hoi district); Ro Koi, Sa Nhon, Sa Son, Mo Rai, Ya Xier and Sa Thay town (Sa Thay district) (Figure 1).
2.3 AHP Management Regime
2.3.1 Establishment, Mandate and Responsibility of AHP
Chu Mom Ray National Park was established in 2002 under the Decision No. 103/2002/QD-TTg of the Prime Minister of the Vietnamese Government dated July 30, 2002 on the basis of re-classification from Chu Mom Ray Nature Reserve because of its high biodiversity and conservation values. The Association of Southeast Asian Nations (ASEAN) recognized the park as an ASEAN Heritage Park in 2003.
The Management Board of Chu Mom Ray National Park was established under the Decision No. 79/2002/QD-UBND of Kon Tum Provincial People’s Committee dated December 23, 2002. The Management Board is under the direct management of the Provincial People’s Committee (PPC) and at the same time under the direction of the provincial Department of Agriculture and Rural Development (DARD). Based on the Forestry Law (2017), Kon Tum Provincial People’s Committee issued Decision No. 635/2020/QD-UBND dated August 27, 2020 to reorganize the Management Board of Chu Mom Ray National Park.
Duties and jurisdiction of the Management Board of Chu Mom Ray National Park are defined in the Decision No. 27/2011/QD-UBND of Kon Tum Provincial People’s Committee dated September 7, 2011 on regulations on organization and operation of the Management Board (Annex 1).
2.3.2 Governance, Organization Structure and Forest Management
The Management Board of Chu Mom Ray National Park includes the following components (Figure 2).
- Key leaders: Director and Deputy Director.
- Offices:
- General Administration Department.
- Department of Science and International Cooperation.
- Specialized forest protection forces (Mobile Forest Protection Team, Technical Team for Disseminating and Handling Violations and 14 Forest Protection Stations).
- Subordinate Unit: Center for Biodiversity Conservation and Ecotourism (reorganized on the basis of Center for Organism Rescue and Development).
| Key leaders01 Director and 02 Deputy Director |
| General Administration Department |
| Department of Science and International Cooperation |
| Center for Biodiversity Conservation and Ecotourism |
| Specialized forest protection forces |
| 14 Forest Protection Stations |
| Figure 2. Organizational diagram of administration in Chu Mom Ray National Park |
The organizational structure of the Management Board is organised and established to fulfill the assigned functions and tasks. In 2019, according to “Decree No 01/2019/ND-CP on forest rangers and specialized forest protection forces dated January 01, 2019”, the forest rangers of the park were restructured and transformed to the specialized forest protection forces. The park has faced many difficulties in the forest management and protection activities, because the specialized forest protection forces have less jurisdiction in handing violations, compared to forest rangers.
- Number of employees
In 2021, the total number of employees is 108 people including 64 officials and 44 labour contracts. The overturn in personnel of the park from 2010 to now is relatively large (average 3 people/year; about 2.7%).
- Personnel qualification
In the CMRNP, the trained employees accounts for a relatively high proportion (75.9%) in the total number of employees. The number of employees with university degrees is quite high (62.2%), thus the implementation of specialized activities is quite well. However, because of difficult and complex working condition, high work pressure and low remuneration, the park still faces many difficulties in keeping employees working stable and long-term. In order to meet the developmental needs and strategies of the park and the forestry sector on sustainable forest development, the Management Board will focus on training staffs in terms of professional expertise, community relation and foreign language skills, and recruit high-qualified employees.
- Natural forest management
The total area managed by Chu Mom Ray National Park is 56,257.2 ha, of which the area of forest and forestry land is 56,249.2 ha. The land of the Park’s headquarters and forest protection stations is 7.93 ha. The management of natural forests is the key task of the park.
- Planted forest management
Up to 2021, the CMRNP has about 193.5 ha of planted forests and 106.38 ha of planting area that has not yet become forests. The main species for forest plantation are native species such as Dalbergia cochinchinensis, Hopea odorata and Senna siamea. In the park, forest plantation activity must be based on suitable silvicultural practices such as planting area, density, species and seedling standard. Due to relatively suitable soil and climate conditions, and effective management, most the planted forests of the park are well developed (survival rate > 85%).
- Forest protection, fire prevention and fighting
Every year, CMRNP develops and implements a forest fire prevention and fighting (FFPF) plan, assigns specific tasks and areas to each forest protection station and involved staffs in order to proactively implement well forest fire prevention and fighting activities.
Up to 2021, the park has built up 11 fire lookout towers, made a system of firebreaks to prevent fire, set up hundreds of signs for banning fire, banning animal hunting, grazing and deforestation. The Park regularly maintains and repairs fire prevention and fighting equipment. The Park has organized annual forest fire prevention and fighting drills such as organizing fire fighting forces and using fire-fighting equipment.
The Management Board of Chu Mom Ray National Park periodically coordinates with local authorities, involved organizations and departments to organize dissemination and communication activity on legal regulations and policies relating to the forest protection and fire prevention in order to raise people’s awareness. Advocating local people and communities to sign the commitments on not exploiting forest products, illegally hunting animals, not violating forest protection and fire prevention regulations.
- Prevention and control of pests and diseases
The Park has assigned specialized staffs to regularly coordinate with forest protection stations for inspection and control of pests and diseases, and regularly cooperates with the district and provincial Forest Protection Department and Plant Protection Department to get information on the occurrence of forest pests and diseases, by which implementing timely suitable handling measures. However, there is limited information available on the measures of invasive species control.
- Non-timber forest product management
The Park has carried out surveys on status, distribution and productivity of main non-timber forest products (e.g., medicinal plants) in order to develop a suitable plan for conservation, development and sustainable exploitation. Developing regulations on sustainable harvest of non-timber forest products (e.g., Calamus sp., Bambusa sp andScaphium macropodum) in the ecological restoration and administrative services subdivions.
2.4 Finance
- Key Finance Resources for Management of the AHP
Total funding for the actual activities of Chu Mom Ray National Park is mainly from the following sources:
- Funding from programs and projects of the forestry sector for forest protection and development activities accounts for the largest proportion. Revenues from payment for forest environmental services (PFES).
- Funding for scientific research, joint venture and funding from international organizations.
The operational funds in the park during the period of 2016-2020 are summarized in Table 2 below.
Table 2. Investment capital of programs and projects in CMRNP in the period of 2016-2020
Unit: million VND
| ID | Financial sources | Total | From 2016 to 2020 | ||||
| 2016 | 2017 | 2018 | 2019 | 2020 | |||
| 1 | Forest protection and development projects (2011-2015); Residual capital | 849 | 689 | 160 | |||
| 2 | Investment project to build the park (2013-2015) | 28,408 | 14,000 | 14,408 | |||
| 3 | Sustainable forestry development program | 29,253 | 8048 | 1,970 | 11,164 | 8071 | |
| 4 | Project of crucial constructions for forest fire prevention and fighting | 3,113 | 3,113 | ||||
| 5 | PFES sources | 26,528 | 2,690 | 4,062 | 7,472 | 7,120 | 5,184 |
| 6 | Planting activity of alternative forests | 5,650 | 1,830 | 864 | 1,040 | 412 | 1,504 |
| 7 | Support 49 villages/hamlets in the buffer zone | 2,821 | 1,957 | 864 | |||
| 8 | Develop sustainable forest management plant (2020) | 1,860 | 1,860 | ||||
| 9 | In total | 98,482 | 21.166 | 13,998 | 24,890 | 18,696 | 19,732 |
Total investment capital of programs and projects in the park in the period 2016-2020 is 98,482 million VND (4,333,208 USD) with annual average amount of 19,696 million VND/year (866,624 USD/year). The actual investment capital accounted only about 28.2% of the approved investment capital (349,055 million VND or 15,358,420 USD) of the park in the period of 2016-2020 (Decision No. 747/QD-UBND dated July 25, 2014).
Actual investment capital was low because two main activities, including (1) ecological restoration and (2) infrastructure development for forest management and forest fire prevention and fighting needed a large amount of capital but not properly invested (just about 15%). Financial sources in the period of 2016-2020 mainly depennded on state budget while funding sources and support from international organization were still limited.
2.5 Natural Values
2.5.1 Biodiversity Characteristics
The natural forests accounting for most of the area of Chu Mom Ray National Park with diverse forest ecosystems that are suitable for the conservation of endangered and endemic flora and fauna species and a great potential in providing forest environmental services.
The area of poor/ degraded forests account for a high proportion (15.9%) in natural forest area of the park. In the future, it is therefore necessary to protect, nurture and develop forests of the park. Endemic and endangered species in the park are at risk of habitat loss due to forest disturbance (e.g., forest encroachment, forest fires).
2.5.1.1 Flora
Chu Mom Ray National Park has 1,895 terrestrial vascular plants belonging to 184 plant families (Table 3). In the park, most of the plant species belong to the Magnoliophyta phylum with 150 families (81.5%) and 1,685 species (88.9%).
Table 3. Plant species composition in Chu Mom Ray National Park
| TT | Phylum | Number of families | Number of species | Proportion (%) |
| 1 | Psilotophyta | 1 | 1 | 0.05 |
| 2 | Lycopodiophyta | 2 | 15 | 0.79 |
| 3 | Equisetophyta | 1 | 2 | 0.11 |
| 4 | Pteridophyta | 30 | 192 | 10.13 |
| 5 | Magnoliophyta | 150 | 1.685 | 88.92 |
| Total | 184 | 1.895 | 100 |
Endangered and endemic species
Flora of CMRNP are typically characterized for the flora in southern Truong Son mountain range (Annamite mountain range). There are 33 endemic species recorded in the forest flora of the park Some endemic species have narrow habitat such as Wrightia kontumensis Lyand Polygala tonkinensis Chodat. Among 1,895 vascular plants, there are 192 endangered species with high economic and conservation values (SFMP, 2021). In which, some species that are in danger of being lost such as Decussocarpus fleuryi and Dipterocarpus grandifloras (Figure 3).
The status of some endangered plant species is showed as follows (Annex 2):
- There are 20 species in the IUCN Red List (2020): 7 endangered (EN), 7 vulnerable (VU) and 6 of low concern (LC) species.
- There are 48 species recorded in the Vietnam Red Book (2007): 14 endangered (EN), 34 vulnerable (VU) species
- There are 26 species mentioned in Decree No. 06/2019 (ND 06) of Vietnamese Government: 2 species are banned from exploitation and use for commercial purposes (IA) and 24 species are restricted from exploitation and use for commercial purposes (IIA).
| Wrightia kontumensis Ly |
| Polygala tonkinensis Chodat |
| http://www.epharmacognosy.com/2021/10/polygala-toankinensis-chodat.html |
| Decussocarpus fleuryi |
| https://tracuuduoclieu.vn/nageia-fleuryi-hickel-de-laub.html |
| Dipterocarpus grandifloras |
| http://cayhoacanh.com/cay-dau-dot-tim-cay-quy-can-duoc-bao-ton/.html |
| Figure 3. Endemic and endangered plants in CMRNP |
2.5.1.2 Fauna
Chu Mom Ray National Park has 1,001 animal species belonging to 6 different classes (mammals, birds, reptiles, amphibians, fish and insects) (SFMP, 2021). Among animal classes, insect class has the largest number of species (41.5%), followed by birds (29.0%), mammals (12.0%), fish (10, 8%), reptiles (4.2%) and amphibians (2.5%) (Table 4). The information other taxa such as Gastropods and Annelids is very limited, and thus researches on these animals are highly needed.
Table 4. Animal composition in Chu Mom Ray National Park
| ID | Class | Number of orders | Number of families | Number of species |
| 1 | Mammals | 10 | 28 | 120 |
| 2 | Bird | 17 | 57 | 290 |
| 3 | Reptile | 2 | 13 | 42 |
| 4 | Amphibians | 2 | 5 | 25 |
| 5 | Fish | 10 | 25 | 108 |
| 6 | Insect | 9 | 48 | 416 |
| Total | 50 | 176 | 1,001 |
- Mammals class
- Cervidae and Tragulidae families: Six species have been recorded including Cervus unicolor, Muntiacus muntjack, Tragulus versicolor, Muntiacus truongsonensis, Megamuntiacus vuquangensis and Cervus porcinus. There are 3 subspecies of Muntiacus muntjack species recorded in Chu Mom Ray National Park, in which Muntiacus muntjak annamensis is endemic to South Indochina (Figure 4).
- Bovidae family: Five species have been recorded in the park. Recent surveys have recorded the appearance of Bos gaurus and Capricornis sumatraensis.
- Carnivores: There are 23 carnivore species belonging to 6 families have been recorded, in which 17 are rare species (e.g., Cuon alpinus, Panthera tigris) (Figure 4). The Park has a highly diverse group of carnivores, accounting for 62.2% of the total number of carnivore species in the country. Therefore, Chu Mom Ray National Park is considered as a conservation area with a high diversity of carnivores in Vietnam, especially large carnivores (the Felidae family).
| Muntiacus muntjack |
| http://www.vacne.org.vn/muntjac-deer-found-in-truong-son-mountains-e32127.html |
| Cuon alpinus |
| http://www.vncreatures.net/chitiet.php?page=2&loai=1&ID=5529 |
| https://en.cand.com.vn/Law-Society/Meet-Vietnam-s-endangered-primates-i415939/l |
| Pygathrix nemaeus |
| Figure 4. Endemic and endangered mammals in CMRNP |
Khỉ đuôi lợn (M. leonine) tại VQG Chư Mom Ray (Nguồn ảnh: VQG Chư Mom Ray)
| Macaca leonina |
| VQG Chư Mom Ray |
The Park has recorded 290 bird species belonging to 57 families and 17 orders. In which, the Passeriformes order has the largest number of families and species with 153 species, accounting for 52.7% of the total bird species, and 28 families, accounting for 49.1% of the total number of bird families in the park. The Park has high diversity of bird resources in terms of order, family and species composition, compared with the bird resources of the whole country; and it is recognised as an Important Bird Area (IBA).
- Class of Reptiles and Amphibians: The park has recorded45 species, 15 families and 3 orders of Reptiles class (about 9% of total number of species in Reptile class recorded in Vietnam).
- Class of Fish: 123 species of freshwater fish have been recorded.
- Class Insects: 416 species have been recorded.
Of the 1,001 animal species recorded in CMRNP, there are 112 endangered species listed in the Vietnam Red Book and IUCN that need to prioritize for conservation, such as Canninmuntiacus truongsonenis, Bubalus bubalis, Bos javanicus, Prionailurus bengalensis, Selerctos thibetanus, Panthera tigris, Pavo muticus, Rheinardia ocellata and Polyplectron germaini (Figure 5).
| Varanus nebulosus |
| Photographs by D. Jestr-zemski |
| Ingerophrynus galeatus |
| Photographs by D. Jestr-zemski |
| Photographs by D. Jestr-zemski |
| Thereuopoda longicornis |
| http://www.birdwatchingvietnam.net/vietnamese-name/germains-peacock-pheasant-198 |
| Polyplectron germaini |
| Figure 5. Some bird, amphibian, reptile and insect species in CMRNP |
2.5.2 Ecosystem Processes
- Ecological services
In CMRNP, the area of 9,683.76 hectares (accounting for 17.9% of the total forest area in the park) are paid for PFES with functions of soil protection and erosion control and water resource retention. The Park has great potential to provide other types of forest environmental services:
- Provide forest environment for eco-tourism, education and entertainment.
- Forests of the park (56.249,23 ha) function as carbon sink with ability to absorb more than 3 million tons of CO2 per year (equivalent to over 15 million USD/year). This is a huge source of income for the Park in the future when the forest carbon market is commercialized.
2.5.3 Social and Cultural characteristics
- Population
In 2020, the total population in the buffer zone communes of CMRNP (8 communes and 1 town) was about 52,880 people, of which Sa Thay town has the largest population (11,082 people), while Sa Nhon commune has the least population (2,256 people). The average population density in the buffer zone is 59 people/km2, the lowest density is in Mo Rai commune (20 people/km2) and the highest one is in Sa Thay town (598 people/km2).
- Ethnicity and culture
The buffer zone of Chu Mom Ray National Park was formerly an area of the New Economic Zones program. In part of this program, people from the northern Vietnam (e.g., Tay, Nung, Thai, Mường, Mông, Dao) migrated to the South and Central region, therefore the ethnic composition in the buffer zone is diverse.
There are 23 ethnic groups living in the buffer zone, in which the majority are Kinh (37.8%), Xo Dang (23.1%), Gia Rai (14.6%) and Muong (8.5%). Proportions of ethnic minorities are different between buffer zone communes. Ya Xier commune has the highest proportion of ethnic minorities (89.4%), followed by Sa Son (84.0%) and Mo Rai (79.2%) communes (Figure 6).
Ethnic minorities all have their own characteristics in terms of customs, festivals, community activities and they still continue to maintain their own activities and customs. Some ethnic minorities such as Ro Mam, H’Lang and Brau have the smallest population in the Vietnamese ethnic community with unique cultural traditions. These unique characteristics will be a great potential for community tourism development (Figure 7 and Figure 8).
| Figure 6. Proportion of ethnic minority groups in buffer zone communes of CMR NP |
| Figure 8. Ceremony of opening paddy grain warehouse of Ro Mam community |
| https://bazantravel.com/le-hoi-mo-cua-kho-lua-cua-nguoi-ro-mam-o-kon-tum/ |
| Figure 7. Rice field god-worshipping ceremony (Jamuchuoi) of Brau community |
| https://baobinhphuoc.com.vn/news/19/94576/le-tria-lua-doc-dao-cua-dan-toc-brau |
- Labour
The working-age population in the buffer zone is at an average level, accounting for 55.4% of the total population of the whole region. Currently, only about 75 – 80% of the labours are employed in the cultivation months, while in other months, about 30% of the labour are unemployed. Local labour resources play an extremely important role in the activities of the park such as forest protection and ecotourism development. However, if there are no reasonable plans use labour forces, this will greatly affect local socio-economic development and forest resource management and protection.
2.5.4 Geological, Topography and Landscape
- Geology and Soil
Soil in CMRNP area is formed mainly from acid magmatic rock and shale and is classified into the following soil groups:
- Red-yellow humus feralit soil: Mainly distributed in the tops and slopes of mountain ranges with elevation > 1,000 m. This soil group has a less typical Feralit process and a relatively strong humusification process. The main reason is due to low temperature and high humidity in high elevation mountains. The characteristics of this soil group are thick litter layer, high proportion of coarse humus, thin soil layer, often acidic soil and soil formed mainly from acid magma parent rock.
- : This soil group distributes mainly in the foothills of the low mountains and hills with the high elevation < 1,000 m. This group of soils has a fairly typical feralit process, very vibrant colours, strong decomposition of organic matter, and a very thorough weathering of parent rock. The characteristics of this soil group are the thick soil layer, medium-light loam soil, and with acidic reaction. In the forested areas, the soil group has a high humus ratio, while in deforested area, the humus ratio is poor. This soil group is formed on 2 types of parent rock, including acid magma and shale.
- Mixed soils in valley: This soil group distributes mainly in the Ya Book valley area. This soil is mainly gleysols, deluvias and mixed products with gravel and coarse grain.
- Topography
Topography of CMRNP has many common features of Kon Tum massif, including the following terrain types.
- Medium and low mountains: This terrain distributes mainly in the areas with high elevation (500 – 1,700m), in the slopes of Ngoc To Lum (1,483m), Ngoc Ia Dron (1,570m), Ngoc Vin (1485m), Chu Kram Lo mountains (1,018m) and Chu Mom Ray mountains (1,782m) and mountain ranges parallel to the Cambodian border. Medium and low mountains are mainly formed by acidic magma parent rock, except for a small area (3-4% of the low mountains) is formed by shale metamorphic rock, thus the topography is mostly peaked and steep, the degree of terrain dissection is very significant, in some places the slope is > 45 o. These medium and low mountains are the main distribution area of tropical evergreen forests with high value for biodiversity conservation of the park.
- Hills: This terrain type distributes mainly in small hills in Ya Book region, areas near the foothills of Chu Hinh, Chu Chok, Ro Koi, Ngoc To Ba and Ngoc Vin mountains. The hilly terrain has slope less than 8o . In hill area, the main vegetations are semi-evergreen broadleaf tropical seasonal rain forest, bamboo and mixed bamboo forests.
- Valley: This terrain type distributes mainly in the Ya Book valley area, formed between mountain ranges extending to the east and west of the park. This is an area with extensive grasslands and is therefore an important habitat for ungulates.
- Landscape
CMRNP has 5 main types of forest vegetations as follows (SFMP, 2021):
1. Mid-mountain tropical evergreen forest: Distributed mainly in the areas with high elevation (1,000 – 1,700 m) in the slopes of the mountains of Ngoc To Lum (1,483 m), Ngoc Ia Dron (1,570 m), Ngoc Vin (1,485 m) and Chu Kram Lo (1,018 m). This vertical forest type distributes mainly in the strictly protected zone of the park with the main dominant species such as Syzygium chunianum, Lithocarpus sp, Acer sp., Dendropanax sp., Litsea sp. It was formerly affected by war and is less affected by human activities.
2. Lowland evergreen forest: Distributed mainly in the areas with elevation from 500 to 1,000 m, in the low slopes of CMR mountain range, the connection area between Chu Do and Chu Hinh mountains (729 m), the area of Chu Chok peak (728 m) and in the mountain ranges parallel to the Cambodian border. The main species in canopy layer are Syzygium chunianum, Lithocarpus sp., Acer sp., Dendropanax sp., Litsea sp., which have high value of biodiversity conservation, a food source for primates, carnivores and small mammals (Figure 9).
| Figure 9. Lowland evergreen forest in CMRNP |
3. Semi-evergreen broad-leaved tropical seasonal rain forest in lowland: Mainly distributed in the in the ecological restoration zone of the park. It covers areas of 300-500 m elevation in the Ya Book region, areas nearby the foothills of Chu Hinh, Chu Chok, Ro Koi, Ngoc To Ba and Ngoc Vin mountains. The emergent layer commonly has some dominant species such as Dialium cochinchinensis, Hopea odorata and Tetrameles nudiflora; and is a very important habitat for large ungulates, monkeys, gibbons, bears and civets due to its proximity to and interspersed with grasslands. It is the corridor connecting with the mountainous evergreen forests in the west and east of the park.
4. Bamboo and mixed bamboo-timber forests: It is distributed in the ecological restoration and administrative service and tourism zones, with 300 – 700 m elevation in the Ya Book region, covers the areas nearby the northern and southern foothills of the park. The predominant bamboo species are Dendrocalamus membranaceus and Oxynanthera zollingera. This type of forest is commonly established after disturbances caused by wars and deforestation in the past. The forest type is now strictly protected; thus, many areas have regenerated and recovered well.
5. Grassland and grassland mixed with shrubs and scattered trees: Mainly distributed in the area of 300 – 700 m elevation in the Ya Book area, the southern foothill of the Chu Kram Lo mountain and the northern foothill of Ngoc Vin mountain. Among the grass species in CMRNP, Imperata cylidrica is dominant, mixed with other grass species. Woody species distributes scatterly in small areas with commonly found species such as Anogeissus acuminatus, Aporusa sp., and Careya sphaerica. Most of these grasslands were formerly heavily sprayed with toxic chemicals in the past. There is limited data of chemical residue. The grasslands are well protected, so many tree species have regenerated leading to the gradual shrinking of grassland area. This is an important habitat for ungulates.
There are secondary moss forests distributing in peaks of Ngoc Vin (1,480m) and Chu Mom Ray (1,773m) mountains, and grasslands in Ngoc To Ba (1,030m) and Chu Do peaks. (1,145m). The type of deciduous broadleaf forest (dipterocarp species) has a small area (140 ha) and distributes in Dak Kan commune of Ngoc Hoi district.
2.6 AHP Sustainable Forest Management Plan
2.6.1 Vision
Sustainable forest management plan (SFMP) of CMRNP in the period of 2021-2030 aims to simultaneously and consistently implement activities of forest management and protection, forest ecosystem and biodiversity conservation, especially endangered and endemic and species. The SFMP plan also aims at restoring degraded forests, developing ecotourism and implementing scientific research and human resource training and development. The SFMP plan will contribute to environmental and natural resource protection, socio-economic developmen, towards sustainable development in all three aspects of economy, society and environment.
2.6.2 Management Objectives
The SFMP plan of CMRNP in the period of 2021-2030 includes objectives of environmental, social and economic development (Annex 3). The key objectives are described as follows.
- Protecting the integrity of the existing forests and increasing the planted forest gradually; increasing forest coverage of the park to reach over 97% by 2030. Protecting populations of endangered and endemic species through monitoring, rescue and conservation. Restoring degraded forests (poor forests), reducing greenhouse gas emissions and enhancing forest carbon stocks, towards achievement of national action program goals on climate change mitigation and other related goals.
2.6.3 Key Threats to AHP Natural Values
The natural values of CMRNP are facing threats from anthropogenic and natural disturbances, especially (1) the problem of illegal logging and forest encroachment, and (2) forest fires.
- Illegal exploitation of forest products and encroachment on forests
In the park, illegal logging and forest encroachment activities have been taking place, causing damages to forest resources and biodiversity. The data of Chu Mom Ray National Park has showed that forest encroachment tended to decrease. For instance, the number of violations to forest resources in 2020 decreased by 86%, compared to 2016 (Table 5).
Table 5. Number of violations on forest protection and biodiversity conservation in CMRNP from 2016-2020
| ID | Violation | Year | Total | |||||
| 2016 | 2017 | 2018 | 2019 | 2020 | ||||
| 1 | Illegal deforestation | 1 | 1 | |||||
| 2 | Illegal logging of forests | 17 | 27 | 8 | 2 | 4 | 58 | |
| 3 | Illegal transportation of forest products | 13 | 9 | 5 | 1 | 28 | ||
| 4 | Violations against regulations on management and protection of wild animals | 1 | 1 | |||||
| 5 | Violation of the state’s general regulations on forest protection | 1 | 2 | 2 | 1 | 6 | ||
| 6 | Hiding illegal forest products | 12 | 5 | 2 | 19 | |||
| Total | 43 | 43 | 17 | 4 | 6 | 113 | ||
- Forest fire
Forest fire is one of the drivers causing negative impacts on forest resources and biodiversity. Slash-and-burn cultivation and the using fire for vegetation treatment are the two main causes of forest fires in CMRNP. Every year, the park develops a forest fire prevention and fighting plan according to the provisions of Article 45 and the Form No. 2 – Appendix III issued together with Decree 156/2018 / ND-CP. Forest fire prevention and fighting in the park include the following activities.
2.6.4 Key Management Issues
- Land-use conflict and deforestation
Until 2020, entire forest area of CMRNP (56,249.23 ha) has been allocated land use rights. However, the current status of land use planning in the park still has some shortcomings. For instance, the 317.35-ha forest area was planned as special-use forests, but in fact, it is agricultural and bare land that has been used for a long time by local people (Bar Goc village area inn Sa Son commune, Lang Re area in Mo Rai commune and Border Guard Station 707) and area for road and border station construction and water body. In addition, agricultural lands of some local households are located in special-use forests, leading to difficulties in forest protection and fire prevention and fighting. In 2018, the swidden area located in the core zone of CMRNP was 386.44 ha. The Management Board of the park has requested to return the agricultural production land to the local management, but has not yet been approved by the competent authorities.
Illegal exploitation of forest products and forest encroachment are threats to forest resources and biodiversity in the Park. Therefore, clearly defining and demarcating the boundary of the park on the map and in the field area very crucial to reduce forest encroachment. The boundary demarcation of the park is being implemted using state investement.
- Difficult working condition
Topographical, climatic and hydrological conditions greatly affect forest management and protection activities. In the rainy season, the system of forest protection patrol roads in many places is divided by streams, causing many difficulties for forest protection activity. In the dry season, the risk of wildfire is likely to occur, especially in the shifting cultivation areas adjacent to the border of the park.
The area of the park is large and the buffer zone is located in an area of 8 communes and 1 town of 2 districts (Sa Thay and Ngoc Hoi) and nearly 30 km of the border of the park adjacent to the Cambodian border. Currently, the on-site forest protection forces are living and working in forests about 5-6 days/week. Many forest protection stations are located in remote areas without electricity from the national electricity lines and low phone signal. Living and traveling conditions face many difficulties, especially in the rainy season. The specialized forest protection forces are not fully equipped with equipment, support tools and defencive weapons, and must regularly conduct patrols in forests for a long time, and often directly face violators who use offensive weapons that are life and health threatening.
- Low awareness of local community on natural values and importance of conservation
The living condition of local people in the buffer zone is still difficult, thus they often go to the forest to collect non-timber products (e.g., burning hives to get honey, picking wild vegetables and catching fish), causing difficulties for fores fire prevention and control. In addition, the awareness of a part of the local people is still low, leading to difficulties in dissemintign on regulations of forest protection and forest fires prevention and fighting.
2.6.5 Status of the SFMP
The SFMP in the period of 2021 – 2030 of the CMRNP has been approved by the Kon Tum Provincial People’s Committee under Decision No. 746/QD-UBND dated August 16, 2021.
2.6.6 Existing Investment and Support
2.6.6.1 Existing Investment
Up to now, the existing invested infrastructure items of the park include (1) buildings for management activity, (2) buildings for forest fire prevention and fighting, (3) buildings for scientific research, and (4) buildings for ecotourism combined with environmental education (Annex 4). Most of the infrastructure constructions in the park have been built for a long time, so many of them have been degraded and damaged. Therefore, investment in repair and upgrading them in the near future is needed.
2.6.6.2 Existing capital
In the period of 2016-2020, the total investment capital for programs and projects in CMRNP is 98,482 million VND (4,336,905.62 USD) with an annual average amount of 19,696 million VND/year (867363.5 USD/year) (refer Table 2). Compared with the approved investment capital of CMRNP in the period of 2016-2020 (349,055 million VND or 15,371,525.7 USD), the actual investment capital accounts only about 30%. Investment capital in infrastructure for forest management, fire prevention and ecological restoration is only about 15% of the allocated budget. According to Decision No. 747/QD-UBND (2014), the approved funding mainly comes from the central budget (90.4%). Funds mobilized from socialization and support from international organizations are very limited.
In the period of 2021-2030, the total investment capital for the SFMP in CMRNP is estimated as 509,934 million VND or 22,329,269 USD (Table 6). Investment capital focuses mainly in plan of forest management and protection, forest use and biodiversity conservation (28.3%), followed by infrastructure construction plan (22.5%), forest protection contract for residential communities (15.2%) and forest development plan (7.1) %). Details of items and investment capital are shown in the Annex 5.
Table 6. Total required investment capital in Chu Mom Ray National Park in the period 2021 – 2030
Unit: million VND
| TT | Items | Total | Ratio (%) |
| Total investment capital 2021-2030 | 509,934 | 100.0% | |
| 1 | Forest protection contract for residential communities | 77,760 | 15.2% |
| 2 | Forest management and protection, forest use and biodivesity conservation | 143,920 | 28.3% |
| 3 | Forest development | 36,084 | 7.1% |
| 4 | Scientific research, teaching, training | 28,550 | 5.6% |
| 5 | Developing eco-tourism and entertainment | 35,600 | 7% |
| 6 | Infrastructure construction and development | 114,400 | 22.5% |
| 7 | Community service | 27,540 | 5.4% |
| 8 | Improving management capacity in PFES, forest environment lease | 1,500 | 0.3% |
| 9 | Awareness raising and education on the law of forest protection and fire prevention | 17,400 | 3.4% |
| 10 | Monitoring forest resources and biodiversity | 3,300 | 0.6% |
| 11 | Equipment purchase | 18,030 | 3.5% |
| 12 | Other expenses (Expense for preparing SFMP plan) | 5,850 | 1.1% |
In the process of implementing the SFMP and the ecotourism development plan, CMRNP will actively seek investment sources from cooperation and forest environment leasing for ecotourism development. In addition, the park will develop a scheme for new PFES implementation and reinvest in forest protection and forest fire prevention and fighting.
2.7 Existing Arrangements for Access to AHP Resources
The forest area of CMRNP being managed is 56,249.23 ha, of which 9,683.7 ha (17.9% of the total forested area of the park) are paid for forest environmental service. The PFES has been paid by hydropower plants for soil protection and erosion control, sedimentation reduction in lakes, rivers in Nam Sa Thay river basin. In 2020, the forest area to be paid for PFES included (1) the area protected by the park (6,292.7 ha) and (2) the area contracted with 8 local communities for protection (3,391.0 ha).
The payment from PFES has created a stable source of income, contributing to forest management activities the park and increasing income of staffs and local people. This has motivated the park’s employees and PFES contracted communities to better patrol and protect forest resources. Expectedly, the forests with PFES scheme is better managed and violations has been relatively controlled. However, because the area of PFES scheme is not large and it does not include all the areas contracted to residential communities, leading to potential conflicts among communities.
2.8 Existing Measures and Mitigations
2.8.1 Measures on forest management and protection, forest development and biodiversity conservation
- Strengthening and arrangement of forest protection forces on the entire area of the park and regularly patrolling to detect and prevent activities that threaten forest resources
- The CMRNP will develop commitments of protecting special-use forests in accordance with current laws and regulations, in the direction of clearly defining the responsibilities of village communities and local authorities in coordinating forest protection.
- The Park will develop regulations on sustainable exploitation of NTFPs in the ecological restoration and administrative services zone.
- The park will focus on increasing community participation in forest protection (Table 7). The subjects contracted for forest management and protection are the communities who have sufficient organizational conditions to perform the contract. In case the number of communities requesting to get contract is larger than the demand, the park will prioritize contracting with ethnic minority households and Kinh’s poor households to help them increase their income.
- The park regularly promotes communication to raise people’s awareness of cooperation and compliance with the park’s regulations on forest management and protection, forest fire prevention and fighting, and environmental protection as well as sustainable exploitation of natural resources.
Table 7. Plan to contract with local community for forest management and protection in CMRNP in the period of 2021-2030
| Period/year | Total (ha) | Natural forest (ha) | |
| In the PFES area | Outside the PFES area | ||
| 2021-2030 | 164,000 | 34,000 | 130,000 |
| 2021 – 2025 | 82,000 | 17,000 | 65,000 |
| 2021 | 16,400 | 3,400 | 13,000 |
| 2022 | 16,400 | 3,400 | 13,000 |
| 2023 | 16,400 | 3,400 | 13,000 |
| 2024 | 16,400 | 3,400 | 13,000 |
| 2025 | 16,400 | 3,400 | 13,000 |
| 2026 – 2030 | 82,000 | 17,000 | 65,000 |
In addition, CMRNP is carrying out procedures to reduce 337.25 ha out of the currently managed forest area. This adjusted area is the concentrated agricultural production area of the people in Bar Goc village (Sa Son commune) and Re village (Mo Rai commune) located within the boundary of the park. This will make the management activity easier and in line with the reality of the park as well as the production activities of local people.
2.8.2 Measures on management and human resources
- Management
The park will consolidate personnel based on the newly reorganized organizational structure according to Decision No. 635/2020/QD-UBND, dated August 27, 2020, of the People’s Committee of Kon Tum Province, especially employees of the Center for Biodiversity Conservation and Ecotourism. The specialized protection force will operate according to the new regulations promulgated in Decree 01/2019/ND-CP of the Government dated January 1, 2019.
- Human Resources
Enhancing human resources and improving the professional qualifications of staff are essential requirements to well implement the forest management and protection, and biodiversity conservation. Therefore, the Management Board of CMRNP will implement measures to supplement and develop human resources in the Park (Annex 6).
2.8.3 Measures on coordination with stakeholders
The Management Board will develop a regulation or contract to coordinate with competent agencies such as police and border guards in forest management and protection and handling hot spots of forest encroachment.
The Management Board cooperates with local authorities to sign commitments on forest protection and forest fire prevention and fighting with local people, and at the same time settle disputes relating to forest management and protection activities. However, less attention is paid to attracting the participation of local communities in forest management and protection and ecotourism development.
2.8.4 Measures on science and technology
The Management Board has applied Remote Sensing (RS), Geographic Information System (GIS), Spatial Monitoring and Reporting Tool (SMART) and information technology in forest survey, forest resource management to properly assess forest and land-use changes, forest growth and regeneration, and biodiversity monitoring. They also actively cooperating with specialized research institutes, universities and international organizations in formulating and implementing activities on scientific research, environmental protection and biodiversity conservation.
2.8.5 Measures on capital sources and mobilization of investment capital
The Management Board plan to call for investment in the form of cooperation and forest environment leasing to develop ecotourism. Promoting and seeking funding sources from local and international NGOs to manage and protect forests and conserve biodiversity. The Management Board will develop a plan to implement a new PFES policy to reinvest in forest protection and forest fire prevention and fighting.
2.8.6 Measures to minimize negative impacts on the environment
In order to minimize environmental pollution, the Management Board implements the following solutions:
- In all construction works, it is required to have an environmental impact assessment submittted to the competent authorities for approval before starting construction. When constructing, it must comply with the government regulations on infrastructure construction in special-use forests, especially the construction of road systems, hotels, water supply and drainage works, entertainment areas and parking places.
- Regularly checking the quality of wastewater systems, collecting and treating waste at sites with tourism and construction activities. Wastewater systems are required to be treated complying to environmental sanitation standards before being discharged into the environment. Buidling garbage collection and treatment systems at all tourist sites and roads;
- Dissemination and raising public awareness on environmental protection, through seminars and media such as books, posters and leaflets.